📋 Written Ability Test (WAT)/Essay Analysis Guide: Is it Moral to Allow People to Sell Their Organs for Profit?
🌐 Understanding the Topic’s Importance
Commercial organ sales bridge ethical considerations and real-world healthcare needs, making it an essential subject for B-school discussions on healthcare management and moral philosophy.
📝 Effective Planning and Writing
- ⏱️ Time Allocation:
- Reading & Planning: 5 minutes
- Writing: 20 minutes
- Review: 5 minutes
- 📖 Preparation Tips:
- Research global models like Iran’s regulated system.
- Study ethical debates from bioethics forums and policy papers.
💡 Introduction Techniques for Essays
- Contrast Approach: “While organ donation saves lives, allowing organ sales challenges our ethical foundations. The dilemma lies between life-saving potential and societal values.”
- Solution-Based Approach: “A regulated organ market could address shortages, but it must ensure equitable access and prevent exploitation.”
📊 Structuring the Essay Body
🏆 Achievements
Highlight reduced organ shortages in Iran and financial incentives as motivators for donors.
⚠️ Challenges with Comparative Analysis
Discuss ethical concerns, exploitation risks, and disparities in unregulated markets. Compare models like Iran’s regulated system and Spain’s altruistic donation policies.
🔮 Future Outlook
Propose frameworks for transparent, ethical organ sales systems that protect vulnerable populations and ensure equitable access.
📄 Concluding Effectively
- Balanced Conclusion: “While organ sales could mitigate shortages, ethical frameworks and equitable regulations are vital to prevent societal harm.”
- Global Comparison Conclusion: “Balancing Iran’s regulated success with Spain’s altruistic leadership could offer innovative solutions.”
📈 Analyzing Successes and Shortcomings
✨ Achievements
Efficient allocation of organs and reduced waitlists in regulated systems.
⚠️ Challenges
Ethical exploitation and inequity in access based on socio-economic status.
🌍 Global Context
Contrast Iran’s regulation with Spain’s altruistic model to highlight potential paths forward.
🚀 Recommendations for Sustainable Progress
- ✅ Legalize organ sales under strict ethical frameworks and oversight.
- 📣 Increase public awareness about organ donation to reduce reliance on sales.
- 🌐 Enhance international cooperation to combat black markets and standardize practices.
✍️ Sample Short Essays
⚖️ Balanced Perspective
“A regulated organ market could save lives but must prevent exploitation through strict oversight and transparency.”
🔧 Solution-Oriented
“The organ shortage demands innovative solutions, and ethical commercialization could offer hope if paired with safeguards.”
🌏 Global Comparison
“Learning from Iran’s success and Spain’s altruistic model, nations can craft ethical and effective policies.”